Kia Telluride and Tesla Model Y Achieve Top Safety Pick+ Rating





In an announcement from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), two popular SUV models, the 2027 Kia Telluride and the 2026-27 Tesla Model Y, have been recognized with the prestigious Top Safety Pick+ award. This commendation signifies their exceptional performance in a series of stringent crash and avoidance assessments. Notably, the Kia Telluride's top rating is contingent upon its manufacturing date, specifically applying to units produced after June 2026, following necessary enhancements to its headlight system. This rigorous evaluation by the IIHS aims to ensure consumers have access to the safest vehicles on the market, with demanding criteria covering various aspects of crashworthiness and crash prevention.
The IIHS conducted thorough evaluations on seven new vehicles this year, with only the updated Kia Telluride and Tesla Model Y emerging with the highest safety distinction. The Telluride’s qualification for the Top Safety Pick+ rating was a result of Kia addressing and improving its headlight performance. Earlier versions of the 2027 Telluride, manufactured before June 2026, did not meet the 'Good' rating standard for headlights, achieving only a 'Marginal' score. This adjustment underscores the importance of every safety component, even seemingly minor ones like headlights, in securing the highest safety accolades.
Conversely, the Tesla Model Y navigated the updated testing protocols with greater ease, securing 'Good' ratings across all categories, including crash tests, headlight performance, and crash prevention systems. This achievement marks a continuous streak of top-tier safety recognition for Tesla's crossover, maintaining its superior safety designation through its recent redesign. However, the Model Y did receive a 'Marginal' rating for its seat belt reminder system, indicating a minor area for improvement despite its overall strong performance.
Several other vehicles subjected to the IIHS’s intense examination, including the BMW 3 Series, BMW i4, Lexus IS, GMC Canyon, and Toyota Crown Signia, did not achieve any IIHS award in this latest round. The GMC Canyon crew cab, in particular, struggled to meet the updated crash-avoidance standards, highlighting the increasing difficulty of the IIHS’s safety benchmarks. These comprehensive tests include evaluations for small overlap front, updated moderate overlap front, and updated side crash performance, with the latter now simulating more severe real-world collisions involving heavier barriers and higher speeds.
The IIHS also emphasizes the significance of crash avoidance systems. Vehicles must demonstrate robust performance in both vehicle-to-vehicle and pedestrian front crash prevention tests, which assess automatic emergency braking capabilities across various speeds and scenarios. This holistic approach to safety testing ensures that vehicles not only protect occupants during a crash but also actively work to prevent accidents from happening in the first place.
For potential buyers, the distinction in safety ratings based on manufacturing dates, especially for the Kia Telluride, means careful consideration is required when selecting a vehicle. Verifying headlight grades and understanding the specific build dates of dealer inventory are crucial steps. The Model Y's consistent high scores solidify its reputation, though the minor flaw in its seat belt reminder system serves as a reminder that continuous refinement is always possible. The evolving nature of IIHS testing standards reflects an ongoing commitment to advancing vehicle safety, pushing manufacturers to innovate and improve for the benefit of all road users.